320 cities · 12,480+ places · updated weekly
Ice Cream Shop 4.8· 172 reviews $

Jeremiah's Italian Ice

Florida, United States

Explore Jeremiah's Italian Ice in Stuart, FL, offering a variety of Italian ice, gelati, and soft-serve treats. Casual spot with indoor/outdoor seating and quick service.

4.8 / 5

Guest rating

172

Reviews

Ice Cream Shop

Cuisine

Florida

City

$

Price level

Closes at 10:00 PM

Overview

About Jeremiah's Italian Ice

Jeremiah's Italian Ice is a casual counter-serve ice cream shop located in Stuart, Florida. It specializes in an extensive selection of frozen treats including Italian ice, gelati, and soft-serve cones, crafted in many unique flavors.

Visitors can expect a quick visit experience with seating available but no table service. The shop offers several service options such as delivery, takeout, in-store pickup, and onsite ordering, making it convenient for different preferences.

The atmosphere is casual, quiet, and trendy, welcoming families, groups, and LGBTQ+ friendly crowds. Accessibility features include wheelchair accessible entrance, restroom, and parking.

Popular treats include Strawberry, Orange Mango Tango, Smores, and Animal Cracker flavors. The shop also features extras like waffle cones and bottled water, alongside jelati cakes in select varieties.

Ice Cream Shop Italian Ice & Gelati Affordable Pricing Family-friendly Wheelchair Accessible Card & Mobile Payments Quick Visit (~15 min) Rated 4.8 (172 reviews)

Quick facts

  • 860 SW Federal Hwy, Stuart, FL 34994
  • +1 772-266-8835
  • Counter-serve, no table service
  • Delivery, Takeout & In-store Pickup
  • Wheelchair accessible entrance & restroom
  • Good for solo dining, families & groups
  • Accepts credit, debit & NFC payments
  • Typical visit lasts about 15 minutes
Amenities & features

What's available at the restaurant

Grouped by category — each group lists what's available and what isn't at Jeremiah's Italian Ice.

Service options

  • Delivery
  • In-store pickup
  • Onsite services
  • Takeout

Popular for

  • Solo dining

Accessibility

  • Wheelchair accessible entrance
  • Wheelchair accessible parking lot
  • Wheelchair accessible restroom

Dining options

  • Seating
  • No Table service

Amenities

  • Restroom

Atmosphere

  • Casual
  • Quiet
  • Trendy

Crowd

  • Family-friendly
  • Groups
  • LGBTQ+ friendly

Planning

  • Quick visit

Payments

  • Credit cards
  • Debit cards
  • NFC mobile payments

Children

  • Good for kids
Hours

Opening hours

When Jeremiah's Italian Ice is open during the week.

Closes at 10:00 PM

  • Monday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Tuesday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Wednesday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Thursday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
  • Friday 12:00 PM - 11:00 PM
  • Saturday 12:00 PM - 11:00 PM
  • Sunday 12:00 PM - 10:00 PM
Location

Location & Nearby Places

Central Florida, with cafes, shops, and other restaurants within easy walking distance.

Reviews

Reviews for Jeremiah's Italian Ice

What recent guests say after dining at Jeremiah's Italian Ice.

4.8/ 5

Based on 172 guest reviews

Strawberry Shortcake Mango Gelato Indoor Seating Peanut Butter Cup Treat Mint Chocolate Chip Gelati Gellati Chocolate Ice Cream Pup Cup Oreo

Rating distribution

5 90%
4 4%
3 2%
2 2%
1 2%

Kaneesha Allen

Jun 09, 2026

"I enjoyed the peanut butter cup treat from Jeremiah’s. I was nervous to try the peanut butter Italian ice layered with chocolate soft ice cream. I always think of Italian ice as sweet, this was a game changer. The combination was genius. They have indoor and outdoor sitting. It a nice place to spend time with family, friends or date night . I can’t wait to try more cool treats!"

Brian Moriarty

Jun 09, 2026

"Danielle and her team were so gracious to serve my whole family right before they closed. It would’ve been easy to turn us away, but instead they made our night! And the Italian ice was sooooo good. We enjoyed the lemon and strawberry lemon. You could taste that it was made fresh. Thank you so much we will be back!"

Krazyk

Jun 06, 2026

"I am absolutely blown away with the Italian ice and ice cream as well as all the different selections and varieties of flavors. The seating area is very spacious inside and outside. The service was great and fast. You can create so many different flavors by layering the options and prices are reasonable. This place is fantastic for a family friendly atmosphere and is also perfect for a date night dessert. I will definitely be a regular here and can’t wait to try more flavors!"

John Garcia-Landry (JC)

May 22, 2026

"Hi everyone, I really enjoy the birthday cake ice cream at Jeremiah’s Italian Ice. It’s one of the best desserts I’ve ever had. They have a great rewards program that makes it easy to redeem points. The staff are always so friendly here as well."

Taylar Schmit

May 22, 2026

"Perfect for a hot day! If you’ve ever had their competitors Rita’s, it is very similar! I’m so happy they put one of these in Martin County. They have a small indoor seating section and areas where you can order inside and outside. I got the cherry and vanilla soft serve one. Lots of variety with the build your own!"

Chris

Apr 13, 2026

"Great Italian Ice/Ice Cream place. They have a ton of different options of Italian Ice. I got the frosted animal cracker and it was great! The line has been out the door since it opened! Will be definitely coming back."

Jake Benedix

Mar 30, 2026

"Best Italian Ice I’ve ever had! I honestly didn’t even know there were chocolate and other ice cream flavors made in Italian Ice. But I am glad there is, because it is delicious and not expensive. The size seen in the photo posted is a small and if you don’t need a lot of sweet to be satisfied then it should well more than enough for you. Great place and got our order within 2 minutes of ordering. Felt clean and had a good vibe to it. Will definitely be back with the fam."

Coley

Mar 13, 2026

"First time here and everything that we tried was super tasty! My daughter got the Oreo Mud pie which she said tasted exactly like the name! Also got two gelato’s one mango and one watermelon the salt ice cream melt in your mouth along with the Italian ice flavor really hit the spot! When walking up we mentioned it was our first time and customer service offered of us free samples if we wanted to try which I thought was really awesome! The vibe sitting outside enjoying it is definitely south Florida lol relaxing and good music. There are two small tables and a nice sit around area."

FAQs

Frequently asked questions

Common questions about visiting Jeremiah's Italian Ice.

The menu includes Italian ice, gelati, soft-serve cones, and specialty jelati cakes with various flavors and combinations available.

Yes, there is indoor seating as well as outdoor seating. Table service is not provided, as it operates primarily as a counter-serve establishment.

Customers can choose delivery, in-store pickup, onsite ordering, and takeout to suit their convenience.

The facility is accessible with a wheelchair-accessible entrance, restroom, and parking lot available for visitors.

Payments can be made via credit cards, debit cards, or NFC mobile payment options.

Most guests spend around 15 minutes at the shop, making it suitable for a quick treat or casual stop.

The shop welcomes families and children and provides a friendly environment suitable for groups of all sizes.

Some popular flavors include Strawberry, Orange Mango Tango, Smores, Animal Cracker, and Peanut Butter Cup.

More options

Similar restaurants nearby

Other places nearby you may also consider.

Mochachos Gold Reef City
Fast Food Restaurant

Mochachos Gold Reef City

Gold reef city, 4 shaft road, Ormonde 99-Ir, Johannesburg, 2159, South Africa

4 View
Recanto da Cidade
Pizza Restaurant

Recanto da Cidade

R. Camerino, 175, Umbaúba - SE, 49260-000, Brazil

4.5 View
Maluce Sorvetes
Ice Cream Shop

Maluce Sorvetes

R. José Theodoro Ribeiro, 4236 - Ilha da Figueira, Jaraguá do Sul - SC, 89258-730, Brazil

4.5 View
Parkway Grille
Restaurant

Parkway Grille

3600 Centerpoint Pkwy, Pontiac, MI 48341, United States

4.2 View
Deguste - Restaurante E Puzzaria
Restaurant

Deguste - Restaurante E Puzzaria

R. Sen. Valter Franco, Areia Branca - SE, 49580-000, Brazil

4.7 View
For business owners

Own or manage this restaurant?

Keep your listing accurate by updating your address, opening hours, menu, photos, and contact details. Reach more diners searching for Ice Cream Shop in Florida on Locallya.

  • Free to claim & verify
  • Edit menu & hours anytime
  • Respond to customer reviews
  • Track views & engagement
Directions Call Menu